Winning picks: A guide to cyclical and defensive stocks

Understanding the difference between two fundamental types of stocks, cyclical and defensive, is the key to reading these seasons. It allows an investor to understand the economic environment they are in and why certain sectors are thriving while others are struggling. This isn’t about timing the market, but about aligning your portfolio strategy with the prevailing economic winds.

The economic engine

At its core, the economy expands and contracts. These phases are driven by factors like interest rates, consumer confidence, employment levels, and corporate investment.

1. Expansion: The economy is growing. Jobs are a lot, consumers are confident and spending money, and businesses are investing for future growth.
2. Peak: The economy is running at full capacity. Growth starts to slow, and inflation often becomes a concern, prompting central banks to raise interest rates.
3. Contraction: The economy is shrinking. Consumers cut back on spending, unemployment rises, and businesses delay investments.
4. Trough: The bottom of the cycle. The economy has stopped shrinking, and the stage is set for a new recovery, often helped by lower interest rates.

Different types of companies perform very differently during these distinct phases.

Cyclical stocks

Cyclical stocks are the high-performers of the economic world. Their fortunes are directly tied to the health of the broader economy. When the economy is expanding and consumers are feeling wealthy, these companies thrive.

What are they? Think of goods and services that are wants, not needs.

• Consumer discretionary: Automakers, airlines, hotels, restaurants, and luxury goods retailers. People buy new cars and take holidays when they have disposable income.
• Industrials: Heavy machinery and construction companies. Businesses invest in new equipment and factories when they are optimistic about the future.
• Financials: Banks tend to do well when the economy is strong, loan growth is high, and interest rate spreads are favourable.
• Materials: Mining and chemical companies that provide the raw materials for construction and manufacturing.

Cyclicals tend to lead the market during the early-to-mid expansion phase. They often perform best coming out of a recession, as investors anticipate a strong economic recovery.

When the economy contracts, these are the first companies to suffer. Consumers delay big-ticket purchases, and businesses cancel expansion plans, causing revenues and profits to fall sharply.

Defensive stocks

Defensive stocks (also known as non-cyclical stocks) are the steady stalwarts of the market. Their business is providing goods and services that people need regardless of the economic climate. They are less sensitive to the ups and downs of the business cycle.

What are they? Think of essential, everyday needs.

• Consumer staples: Companies that sell food, beverages, household products, and personal care items. People still need to buy groceries and toothpaste in a recession.
• Utilities: Electricity, gas, and water providers. People keep the lights on and heat their homes no matter what.
• Healthcare: Pharmaceutical companies, hospitals, and health insurance providers. People get sick and need medicine in good times and bad.

Defensive stocks tend to outperform the broader market during the late expansion and contraction phases. When economic uncertainty rises, investors flock to these companies for their stable earnings and reliable dividends.

Their stability is also their weakness in a bull market. During a strong economic expansion, they will typically lag the high-flying performance of cyclical stocks. They offer protection, not explosive growth.

How to use this knowledge

Understanding this dynamic is crucial for building a resilient portfolio.

• Look at your own portfolio. Is it heavily weighted towards exciting , cyclical tech and consumer stocks? If so, you are making a strong bet on continued economic expansion.
• A balanced portfolio typically includes a blend of both cyclical and defensive stocks. The defensive portion acts as a shock absorber during downturns, while the cyclical portion provides the engine for growth during upturns.
• By paying attention to economic indicators, like interest rate announcements, inflation data, and consumer confidence surveys, an investor can get a sense of which season we are in. This provides crucial context for why certain parts of their portfolio are outperforming and helps them avoid making panicked decisions based on short-term sector rotation.

Ultimately, the market is a complex ecosystem. But by understanding the fundamental difference between the companies that thrive in the sun and those built to withstand the storm, you can navigate its changing seasons with far greater confidence and clarity. BROKSTOCK provides you with the factual information to make informed market decisions.

Disclaimer:

Any opinions, views, analyses, or other information provided in this article are shared by BROKSTOCK SA, trading as BROKSTOCK, strictly as general market commentary and educational material. This content is not, and should not be construed as, financial advice under the FAIS Act of 2002. BROKSTOCK SA does not warrant the correctness, accuracy, timeliness, reliability, or completeness of any information derived from publicly available third-party research. You must exercise your own judgement in all aspects of your investment decisions, which are made entirely at your own risk. BROKSTOCK SA and its employees accept no responsibility and shall not be held liable for any direct or indirect loss, including (without limitation) loss of profit, arising from reliance on this commentary. The information is intended for educational purposes only and may change at any time without notice. BROKSTOCK SA is an authorised Financial Services Provider – FSP No. 51404. T&Cs and Disclaimers apply: https://brokstock.co.za/